The easiest thing to do is to react
to people and what they have to say. If we heed the message, than focus on the
messenger, we will surely benefit more.
|
The forum where Aamir spoke on intolerance in India Picture Courtesy: Internet |
I
listened to what actor Aamir Khan had to say about the much debated issue of rising intolerance in India. And I do believe
he has spoken as a citizen who is genuinely concerned – much like any of us is.
I don’t think anyone must evaluate what Aamir and Kiran are feeling, and what
Aamir has shared, as what an Indian Muslim has to say.
What is
being said, the message, is clearly more important than who is saying it. This
is not about the intolerance debate that rages on in India alone. This is about
anything, in any context – the message is always more important than the
messenger!
Yet,
ever so often “How dare you?” assumes more significance in your head over
someone telling you something that you don’t want to hear, than what is being told
to you. This “How dare you?” drowns reason and leads to inaction. Simply
because your mind – the human mind thinks 60000 thoughts daily – is filled with
negativity over who delivered the message to you. When your mind is agitated,
obviously, clarity takes a backseat.
To be
sure, even Vaani and I have often, in recent times, thought about relocating from
India at some time in the future. Of course, we have our bankruptcy to deal with
and all our creditors to repay first before we even think of and for ourselves.
The reason why we may even consider moving out of India, if at all we do in the
future, is pretty much similar to what Kiran and Aamir may have shared among
themselves. This beautiful country of ours is becoming more and more intolerant
to not just religion but even to individual opinion. The way Aamir and Kiran
are being trolled is evidence of this disturbing trend growing. People disagreeing with Aamir is fine - but so much hate, so much anger, this is totally unnecessary and avoidable. The truth is social media
has given anyone who has an opinion (all of us have opinions, don’t we?) a
pedestal – not just platform – to flaunt it. So people don’t really bother
about what they have to say. They just want to be seen saying it – something,
anything! This cacophony is harmless if it stayed purely at a noise level. The
tragedy is that our government, our politicians and those who peddle religion, seize
the opportunity and unfairly play up our diversity, pitting gullible masses
against one another. If this trend continues and grows, as it threatens to, it
will make India a sad, a very sad, place. But let me clarify that this change
in perception and preference in Vaani and me is more recent. Over 20 years ago,
I had turned down a job offer from a large American MNC. Simply because the
offer involved migrating to the US. Vaani and I then wanted to stay back in
India, we wanted to do something for our country, living and working from here.
I am
amazed that in two decades we have changed our view. And therein lies the crux
of the issue – we are dealing with growing intolerance for individual opinion
and sentiment in India. Period. Our constitutional right of freedom of
expression stands challenged – and, sadly, in some cases, is stifled or even
denied. Unless we recognize and internalize this message – instead of shooting
the messenger(s) – we can’t bring about lasting, social change.
Today is
Guru Nanak’s (1469 ~ 1539) birthday. If he gave the world one unputdownable
message, this is it: “I belong to no caste”. I hope a few of us, who, to begin
with, share Nanak’s philosophy and outlook to Life, work to spread the message
of harmony and co-existence. Even if we don’t
agree with what someone has to say, let us stop reacting and, important, let is
stop shooting the messenger(s)!
Avis:
ReplyDeleteI appreciate what you have said and can understand the sentiments behind it. At the same time may I also respectfully point out that the reactions against aamir were not in the least extreme. Sure he was ribbed and trolled mercilessly online but rarely did it degenerate into abuse or threats. Nobody is questioning or disputing Aamir's right to state his concerns. However, don't you think by extension others who were hurt by what he said or what they thought he said also have the right to say their piece? Its healthy democracy at play.
I have also had a chance to look at the statistics related to violence and intolerance and the stats paint a different picture. 2015 has actually had fewer incidents of communal violence! Is it wrong then to suspect some bias and/or foul play? I am no modi bakth or bjp fan but I also feel that just because we don't like the man we should not judge him or the party by a different yardstick.